Friday,
September 03, 2010
24 Elul, 5770
News
France
UK
Germany
Western Europe
Eastern Europe
EU-Israel affairs
US 2008 ELECTION
Iran - Holocaust
Conflict in Gaza
Voices
Culture
In Depth
Mideast Crisis
World Cup
On Anglo Jewry
Week at a glance
France Election
EU and Annapolis Summit
News from outside of Europe
Holocaust Remembrance Day
Mumbai Terror
DURBAN II
WILLIAMSON
Stories from our Readers
The Calendar
Links
advertisement
advertisement
LEARN HEBREW

British politicians denied Jews special treatment
Updated: 27/Mar/2007 13:42
Historians and politicians have hit back at claims that war time Prime Minister Winston Churchill was anti-Semitic.
Page tools
Email to friend
Print this page
Bookmark this page
Add your view

LONDON (EJP)--New documentation released by Britain’s National Archives has revealed that English politicians denied Jewish refugees from Europe any “special treatment” during WWII, despite the ongoing persecution from the Nazis.

In secret security service documents released by the NA last week, a memo from the Home Office stressed that each case would be judged individually.

The 1940 memo said: “There is no special treatment adopted towards Jews. They must be brought before a tribunal and if they are established as bona fide refugees their registration books will be stamped ‘refugee from Nazi oppression.’”

Churchill claims rebuffed

Meanwhile, historians and politicians have hit back at claims that war time Prime Minister Winston Churchill was anti-Semitic.

A document from 1937 uncovered by writer Richard Toye during research for a book on Churchill and a previous prime minister David Lloyd George, seemed to show Churchill had negative views towards Jews.

In the document, Churchill allegedly wrote that he supported the idea that the “separateness of the Jew” sometimes caused their own persecution.

And while he described Jews as “sober, industrious and law-abiding,” Churchill was quoted as saying “There are times when one feels instinctively that all this is another manifestation of the difference.”

Never printed

According to Toye the document came from an article to have been printed in a magazine but was pulled. Toye said he believed the document was significant. He said: “While most people would accept that Churchill was no anti-semite, this sheds fascinating new light on his views, which were very inconsistent. He uses some very unfortunate stereotypes.”

“This shouldn’t be taken out of proportion. He had plenty of other opportunities to state his views but didn’t.”

However, official Churchill biographer Sir Martin Gilbert said the article was ghost written and did not represent the politician’s views.

And another historian Richard Langworth, who works at the Churchill Centre, said: “We at The Churchill Center would have fallen off our chairs too - if Churchill had written such words. But Churchill did not write them. Nor did he publish them. Nor did he approve of them.”

Langworth added that Leave Churchill’s had a lifelong support of Zionism and numerous Jewish friends.

“Churchill was a friend of the Jews because, as a moral man, his sense of justice was revolted by persecution. "How can any man be discriminated against," he once asked, "purely because of how he was born?"”


Add Your View Email to friend Print this page Bookmark this page
Latest Articles
Pope wants 'respectful' deal between Israelis, Palestinians
EU official 'skeptical' about Washington talks, stresses influence of ‘Jewish lobby on Capitol Hill’
German central bank votes to exclude disputed member
Netanyahu to Abbas: 'you are my partner in peace'
Jerusalem to remain 'undivided capital of Israel', aide to Netanyahu says
France and Russia urge Mideast parties not to cede to provocation
German central bank mulls director's ouster
 
Jdate